A question about spoiler policy when discussing TV shows on convention panels, prompted by an experience at Redemption 07 last weekend.
I watched one panel, and took part in another, that discussed
Battlestar Galactica. In both cases, the spoiler policy was that we should not discuss Season 3 at all, because as it had only been broadcast on satellite/cable, and no DVD had yet been released, not everyone had had the chance to see it. I was a bit taken aback by this, as in my experience spoiler policy has usually been 'it is reasonable to discuss material that has been shown in the UK
via the medium where most people will see it. In other words, if a series is previewing on cable but is going to be broadcast on terrestrial, it is fair to consider it spoiler-prone. But if it is only going to be on Sky for the foreseeable future, is that not how most people are going to see it? Given that the panel I was on was discussing politics, and some of the most interesting stuff in
BSG happens early in Season 3 (as in
blatant glorification of terrorism!) this was quite a constraint.
So, here are three different scenarios, depending on whether a series will show on satellite/cable then terrestrial, satellite/cable only, or where it's not due for a UK broadcast at all:
[
Poll #936197]